Logistics Demand Driven by Prices as well as Technology, Demographics

This real estate cycle is remarkable for its length and the shift in activity between property types. Single family homes have given way to apartments; retail has ceded ground to industrial and logistics. Technology and demographics are often seen as the big drivers of change but there is a more basic explanation that comes from economics.  Behind the scenes, as always, prices are playing a part in reallocating resources.

Figure 1 shows market growth over the last five years of all the major retail product categories, in both value and volume terms. Values represent the total dollar amount of goods sold (price times quantity) in a product category and is the normal way in which retail sales is measured in the U.S. It can be misleading when prices are falling as they have been for retail products such as electronics and recreation commodities. Volume represents the actual quantity of good sold. Figure 1 shows that volume growth has been much higher than value growth in many sectors because the price of goods sold in these sectors has been declining. In business terms, retailers have had to sell more items to gains the same level of turnover.

Of course, consumers are reaping the gains of falling prices. Each year that prices fall, $100 goes further in the shops.  This may be one reason why wage growth in the US economy has not been as high as expected as unemployment has fallen[1].  However, price deflation poses operational challenges to retailers, particularly those in the middle market. It requires constant cost discipline and efficiency gains, which are not easy when other costs are rising. This is a major reason why e-commerce is doing so well. The ability to handle volume growth efficiently with lower distribution costs has given omnichannel and internet retailers a better position in environment in which it is very hard to raise prices.

Retailers can respond and they are responding.  Michael Porter (Professor, Harvard Business School) tells us there are three generic business strategies: product differentiation, cost leadership and niche. Retailers must be very clear on which strategy to adopt, and not get caught in the middle. Product differentiation is about effective branding and higher levels of service. Retailers who adopt this strategy will link their products to rapidly evolving lifestyles, with attractive and persuasive advertising. Viable strategies exist in goods categories where cost leadership is important, particularly around regularly discounting and bargain hunting. Costco and T.J. Maxx are good at this.  Niche can also work, particularly around locally produced artisan products.

 

Price deflation in this economic cycle has also had the effect of hiding a mini-consumer boom taking place in the U.S. economy. The U.S. non-oil trade balance is at the highest ever (Figure 2). The country is importing manufactured goods at the highest rate ever and these goods are flowing through the increasingly vibrant logistics sector. However, a consumer boom, even one that is obscured by data, is a good environment for retailers, if they adopt the right strategy.  Shopping center owners and managers can help by shifting the retail mix towards health and personal care, food and beverage, niche and branded goods, where price pressures are less intense.

Will falling good prices go on forever?  It is possible things will ease up over the next few years.   After an extended period of low inflation, prices are picking up due to healthy levels of demand. In addition, the likelihood that manufactured goods prices will continue to fall due to off-shoring and globalization seem much diminished. Ultimately, retailing is a social activity, which is as much about leisure as it is buying goods and services. Retailers and retail centers are rapidly changing to compete in this territory but they will have to continue to be highly responsive to the clear signals being sent by prices.

By Richard Barkham, Global Chief Economist, CBRE.

[1] A situation like this has prevailed in japan over the last 20 years.